The NIAA explains the legal inability to prevent the sale of Aboriginal housing in Mount Isa by the local council, noting that Queensland legislation overrode existing caveats intended to protect the properties.
Speakers: Hon Malarndirri McCarthy, Julie-Ann Guivarra, Senator Lidia Thorpe, Dr Simon Gordon, Unknown Speaker
First NationsSocial servicesHon Malarndirri McCarthyJulie-Ann GuivarraSenator Lidia ThorpeDr Simon GordonUnknown SpeakerSenate Finance and Public Administration Legislation CommitteeSupplementary Budget Estimates 2026–27Senate Finance and Public Administration Legislation Committee, 26 Oct 202615085
Transcript
Senator Lidia Thorpe
Uh thank you for appearing today.Uh my first question is about Mount Isa.Um this is to the minister. Um MinisterMcCarthy, when did you and your officebecome aware of issues with a housingprovider that was responsible formanaging ainal housing in Mount Eiza?
Hon Malarndirri McCarthy
>> Sure. Thank you. Uh Senator Thorpe, Iknow we've um provided information toyou uh in the Senate in terms of yourOPD. Uh I believe I responded to yourquestion on this uh in the Senate that Ifirst became aware of it in April.
Dr Simon Gordon
>> April.>> Uh thank you. So according to your
Senator Lidia Thorpe
department's understanding of the Katsyact, what steps were available to youand NY to prevent the loss of thesehomes that were under the corporation'smanagement and so many people includingelders losing their homes.
Hon Malarndirri McCarthy
Yeah, look, we went through quite a lotof um steps and many processes in termsof uh firstly what could we do with thecorporation and uh I'll I'll go to theuh NIAA in a moment, but I do want to[laughter] put on the record uh therewas considerable work done between uhthe NIAA office in Mounter with staffhere. Uh certainly I went to Mount Eiseruh to meet with families uh trying tolook at uh working [clears throat] withthe Mountaer Council. Uh they wereperhaps my first port of call to reallysee uh if this debt could be waved forstarters. Uh just what was it that theywanted. I reached out to the Queenslandgovernment uh for uh their assistance aswell given there was a legacy issuearound the houses in terms of formeragreements with the state uh and ofcourse through um Oric itself to see ifuh we could look at other options interms of trying to assist uh thesefamilies. But I'll I'll hand over toNIAA in terms of some of the moretechnical aspects of it. Senator,
Julie-Ann Guivarra
>> Um, thank you, Senator. Um, as theminister said, uh, we, uh, became awareof the situation with the houses inMount Eiza when it was actually theMountaer Council that reached out to usum, seeking uh, the withdrawal ofcaveats which were over the properties.Those caveats existed back from when uhthe organization in question wasactually um uh under ATSIC. Uh and uh weactually did look at that issue aroundwhether those caveats uh would apply ina circumstance where a local council wasactually seeking to um uh basicallyreclaim rates through the sale of thoseproperties. it. We we found through thelegal advice that in fact um theQueensland government and localgovernment acts in Queensland actuallygaze any uh rights we had to um preventthose sales from happening through thecaveat itself. Um as the minister hasalso noted, we did go through a a rangeof different consultations with theMountaer Council at every level. So Ihad uh meetings with the um the mayorand and counselors. The minister did aswell. Um our office in uh in Mount Aizahad done similarly throughout thisprocess.>> Um we'd also reached out to thedepartment of housing and public worksin Queensland who are actuallyresponsible for social housing.>> Could