AFPNational securityAntisemitismKrissy BarrettSpeaker 1Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee [Part 2]Supplementary Budget Estimates 2026–27Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee [Part 2], 27 Oct 20268747
Transcript
Speaker 1
Thank you very much. We will resume ourcall officers from the AustralianFederal Police. Uh thank you very muchfor joining us later on the program thanyou were scheduled. Uh you have we haveyour uh opening statement table, but Iunderstand there's a couple of thingsthat you wanted to say before we proceedto questions.
Krissy Barrett
>> Thank you, Chair. I think just given uhwhat what's occurred over the last week,there's some important messages that I'dlike to read uh this evening. Uh so goodevening. Tonight, the AFP provides ourongoing thoughts for the member forIndai, Dr. Helen Haines, and her familywho have chosen strength and braveryover anger and despair. Senators, thereis a heaviness that hangs acrossAustralia after the horrifying eventlast week. The alleged offender accusedof attacking Dr. Haines is before thecourt facing a number of charges. I amlimited in what I can say about thisVictoria Police investigation. However,I can reaffirm that the alleged offenderwas unknown to the AFP.Across the world, we are witnessing atrend where violence emerges with littleor no warning, particularly whereindividuals do not have a protectionintelligence footprint. Lone actors arebeing motivated by a convergence ofpersonal grievances, mental healthvulnerabilities, and ideologicalconcerns.What helped keep us safe in recenttimes, such as our geography, analogsystems, and faraway criminals, has beenimpacted by fully integrated technology,social media, and artificialintelligence. Tech has enabled aninstant pipeline of hate. This pipelineof rapid rage, often unhinged andviolent, is being homed delivered or tothe places we work because of thedevices we use. The threats are instantand they're voluminous and theyinstantly shock and cause legitimatefear. Perceived or real anonymity hasgiven cowards courage. When I'm askedwhat has changed in recent years, thisis what has changed. The vector of techand social media is converging with theangry, the haters, the unstable, and theamoral who wrongly believe threats andviolence are tolerable if their cause isnoble. The contagion of online hate hasbreached the digital compound and isspilling into the physical world. Thisis corroding our communities and hasnormalized violence and it continues toimpact on many, most notably the Jewishcommunity. Anti-semitism is often theearly warning sign of a decay in oursociety and the poisoning of our compactwith each other. History shows us this.Words can become deeds that foreverchange our country's values and moralcompass. Our collective consciousnessmust be awake to this threat andacknowledge there will always be anothertarget group of hate if we do notrecognize where it can start. This iswhy in October last year I announced thenational security investigations teamswhich I call flying squads of hatedisruptors. These NSI teams target highharm anti-semitic individuals and theyhelp ring fence our democracy byinvestigating those who threatenCommonwealth parliamentarians and highoffice holders. Our investigators arecharging almost one person a week fortargeting Commonwealth parliamentariansor high office holders.From the 1st of January to the 1st ofJuly this year, the AFP received 785protective security reports that containadverse content about federalparliamentarians.Adverse content does not always meet acriminal threshold. However, the AFPtakes all reports seriously. Whenadverse content does not meet a criminalthreshold, it is used to inform ourassessment of threat, risk, andvulnerability. Of those 785 reports, 50%were directed at male parliamentariansand 47% were directed at femaleparliamentarians. The remaining 3% weregeneric threats to politicians. Femaleparliamentarians were three times morelikely to report receiving offensive orthreatening contact that was sexualizedor gender-based. in nature. Femaleparliamentarians from culturally andlinguistically diverse communities werealso more likely to experience frequentand varied offensive contact. The thethreat themes directed at maleparliamentarians also include threatsgenerally gendered in nature withaccusations of weakness, femininity, orsubordinate masculine traits. Our caseload shows that threats toparliamentarians generally relate tofour key aspects. policies, perceivedperformance, profile, and personality.It would be wrong to think onlyinflammatory comments are creating theflood of threats. In some cases, justthe debate causes the hate. In somecases, parliamentarians are beingtargeted because of their accent, whatthey look like, or their politicalparty. The fact is this, at times thereis an almost immediate link from apolicy announcement or comment to athreat being sent. But that should notbe taken as veiled advice. I'm providingthis information to explain what we arerecording in our case load and tohighlight there is not one singlemeasure alone that will stop the threatsbecause this goes to a wider societalproblem Australia is facing. The AFP isnot here to make judgment on howparliamentarians do politics but we arehere to help keep federalparliamentarians and high office holderssafe. We work closely with theDepartment of Home Affairs and theDepartment of Finance which areresponsible for the security ofelectorate officers and the homes ofparliamentarians.I want to thank every member within theAFP who keeps parliamentarians safe.However, we will do better in showingyou how we take these threats seriouslyand we will introduce better trainingand consistency in this approach.I will also raise the issue ofdemocratic and parliamentarian securitywith state and territory policecommissioners at an upcoming meeting.Chair, I'll leave it there, but justbefore I finish, just very quickly, um Iwill pay tribute to Deputy CommissionerIan McCartney this evening who aftermore than 30 years of service with theAFP will retire in coming weeks. Ian hasoften been at the forefront of combatingthe worst of humanity while maintaininghis own. Ian retires with enormousgratitude from myself and the 8,000members of the AFP.>> Finally, I acknowledge the service ofshadow home affairs spokesman JonoDonium.>> Senator Duniam, you have asked the AFPtough questions and you have rightlyheld us accountable to the public andyou have done this with respect and withthe graciousness of a politician withthe best interests of Australia in yourheart and your mind. Thank you.
Speaker 1
>> That is a lovely way to [laughter]finish an opening statement. SenatorDuniam, you've got the call